The latest surprise in my world
was finding a dead body. That isn’t to say I’ve never been with someone when they’ve died. As a nurse, that sort of thing is
taken for granted. There’s just something very different about stumbling upon a
dead stranger in the dark.
Along with two other drivers, an EMT
friend and I were the first at the scene of a crash in a rural area this last weekend. It was sometime around 2am, and to cut a long
story short, we eventually found the driver, pulse-less and cool beyond resuscitation. That is the undramatized version, devoid of
all the details that make a moment so real, yet so eerily strange.
Later came the getting
over the shock, the “was-that-really-real?” moment of processing followed by guilt
at not feeling more sympathetic for the man, then mild horror and sadness for a
few minutes before shelving it in our minds with all those other seemingly surreal
life events.
What shocked me more than the
actual event was the way people I knew responded to the story. For some reason, to speak about a mildly
violent death is somewhat taboo, which I find ironic in a society which has a massive amount
of media depicting death and gore of some variety. One of my friends excused
themselves mid-story: they felt sick. The very friend who occasionally spends
hours per week playing Halo and watching horror films was disturbed by a
traffic accident so clean it would have been rated a low PG-13.
While many Americans will see
fictional characters die umpteen times, feel distaste for the plight of starving
African children, and vote for capital punishment, we will know little to
nil of the last moments of our own friends and neighbors. I will not see photographs of the murder-suicide that happened at the local park.
I will see smiling memorials, a closed coffin, or perhaps a made-up, waxy-clean version of a human shell.
While we could sit through the Dark Knight Rises without feeling
squeamish, set Average Joe in a clean hospital room with a dying person, and he
will feel numbness, panic, helplessness, discomfort, and horror that no screen
can ever convey.
I’ll disclaim here that this is a
vastly complex (and fascinating) issue.
We must factor in coping mechanisms, the WAYS in which media portrays
death, religion, human nature, general cultural attitudes, the effects of trauma, etc. It deserves books, and books have been
written. Yet for all of our arguing about violent culture, I wonder if we
understand raw death less than ever. We
have distanced and sterilized death until it is little more than losing a video
game, not a final breaking between body and soul but a sort of clean
disappearing act that all humans eventually do and we are allowed to shrug off.
As real death becomes more and more
a mystery, our morbid fascination with this enigmatic instant grows and spills
over into our conversation, our humor, and yes, our media. Eventually, these distant reenactments, these
far off representations we have grown comfortable with, become our only
knowledge of death itself. Meanwhile, our own impending deaths become
increasingly awkward, frightening, and taboo subjects. Do not bore us with another television story
about murder, for we have seen it once already, seen them all. Yet allow a
shooter into my theater, allow me to stumble across an unfortunate driver,
force me to spend hours listening to death rattle breathing of a loved one, and
any numbness I’ve felt towards death must eventually melt away for a little
while. Is it any wonder that during weeks after 9/11/01, church attendance spiked?
Old statistics predict that by the
age of 18 you most likely will have seen anywhere from 18,000 to 26,000 movie
murders, if you are a near-average American [1]. Yet for many, one dead body with almost no blood
on the side of the road remains a traumatic experience. Violence, murder and death are all blights
which have stalked us since Cain killed Abel, and I do not think our attitudes
towards them ought to be dismissed with simple explanations. However, I wonder if at times our callous jokes, our
glorification of violent villains, and our ability to shrug off war
photographs does not spring from our
saturation with death knowledge, but a near-adolescent lack of firsthand experience
with it.
I spent 20 minutes waiting for the police in the dark with a dead man this last Friday. Even for someone who sees death at a higher rate than most, this unnerves me a little in retrospect. Death left its procedural hospital, and found its way into my lake shore weekend. Does violent media numb us to this? I’m not sure.
In such moments, a screen does not protect us from reality.
Sources cited: [1] Senate Committee on the Judiciary. Children, violence, and the media: a report
for parents and policy makers. September 14, 1999.
Slightly dour holiday thoughts.